A Foreign Service career takes the guts out of people. ~ Ambassador Evan Galbraith, political appointee
The Spoils System
An often told story in the State Department has it that former ambssador to Moscow John Matlock was a guest on a U.S. aircraft carrier in the Persian Gulf some years ago. The admiral who hosted him remarked that after he retired, he was thinking of getting himself appointed as an ambassador somewhere. Matlock reportedly rejoined that after retiring he was thinking of getting himself named as an admiral in charge of an aircraft carrier. "But it takes decades of training and highly specialized knowledge to run an aircraft carrier," the astonished Navy man replied. "So does running an embassy," Matlock shot back.
The United States is the only industrialized country to sell its ambassadorships to the highest bidders in an outmoded diplomatic spoils system that rivals any such corruption in any banana republic, dictatorship or two-bit monarchy. Military flag officer positions were similarly sold up until the end of the civil war when the public recoiled at the extent of needless slaughter brought on by incompetent politically appointed generals like Daniel Sickles, whose insubordination at the Battle of Gettysburg caused over 4,000 Union casualties. Congress outlawed the practice of military patronage. But ambassadorships continue to be available to any monied dolt with party connections.
Rogue's Gallery
In an earlier post ("Love, Romance & Sex in the U.S. Foreign Service - Part I: Of Lust & Loneliness"), I suggested that someone needs to collect 200 years of lore on the idiots who are allowed to buy United States ambassadorships. I haven't done that, but here is just a sampling of some of the most memorable idiots and their disservice to their country:
- Joseph Kennedy, a major donor to Democrats in the 1930s and President Franklin Roosevelt’s ambassador to Britain, resigned in disgrace after proclaiming democracy “finished in England” in the wake of Adolf Hitler’s early victories in WWII. Another Roosevelt appointee, wealthy financier Bernard Baruch's brother, caused sex scandals while serving as ambassador to Portugal and again when he was transferred to the Netherlands.
In fact, ambassadorial sexcapades feature prominently among this crowd --
- Former U.S. Ambassador to Norway Mark Evans Austad, an outspoken former Mormon missionary who hurled verbal attacks against a variety of Norwegian liberal institutions as well as the press was taken by police at a house where he was bellowing loudly and banging on a woman's door at 3 a.m. Austad claimed that, after hosting a cocktail party, he headed to a friend's house "to plan a salmon fishing trip," and the taxi had taken him to the wrong address. The police returned Austad to his residence.
- Joseph Zappala, a wealthy Florida developer and fundraiser for President George H.W. Bush, was appointed ambassador to Spain despite his inability to speak Spanish. Zappala's tour in Madrid was marred when he took up with another woman, ending his 30-year marriage. "This guy's roaming eye for the Spanish ladies became very embarrassing for us in the career Foreign Service," said someone who served in Madrid under Zappala.
Otherwise, many incompetent politically appointed ambassadors distinguish themselves by mere public embarrassments and varying levels of damage to U.S. foreign policy --
- In the late 1980s, our ambassador to Italy was an Italian-American lumber baron from Minnesota, Pete Secchia. Having donated generously to his party, Secchia got the job, though he possessed no diplomatic or related experience. An otherwise gregarious sort, he was at sea in Rome. He used one of the most sensitive communications channels, normally reserved for matters of high policy, to update the Secretary of State on his project to remodel Villa Taverna, the U.S. ambassador's residence, including one lengthy cable on his selection of curtains. He was also fond of telling demeaning Italian jokes before crowds of host country officials and journalists, an act that endeared neither him nor the United States to the Italian public.
- Jimmy Carter's ambassador to Singapore, a former South Dakota state legislator, walked off with the ambassadorial china upon completion of his unremarkable assignment. Upon being asked to return the expensive, eagle-embossed dinnerware, our ambassador refused, stating it was his just reward for having been an ambassador.
- And then there's the peculiar case of William A. Wilson, Ronald Reagan's friend and the first U.S. ambassador to the Vatican. In January of 1986, Wilson embarked on an unauthorized diplomatic mission to Libya and secretly met with Libyan strongman Muammar Gaddafi in an effort to open relations between the two countries. Secretary of State George Shultz officially reprimanded Wilson.
- Evan Galbraith, a wealthy non-French-speaking investment banker who served as Reagan's first ambassador to France, may have set a record by receiving four formal protests from the French foreign ministry, the last for an interview he gave in 1985 in which he slammed the government of President Francois Mitterrand for inviting Communist ministers in his Cabinet and in which he enthusiastically predicted that the ruling Socialist Party would go down in defeat in the upcoming French elections. Not exactly a team player, Galbraith, too, was publicly rebuked by Shultz for stating that a Foreign Service career "takes the guts out of people."
- Another potential trap for inexperienced diplomats is "clientitis," or identifying too closely with the host country while losing sight of U.S. policy interests. An egregious example of "going native" was U.S. Ambassador to Romania James Rosapepe, a Clinton appointee who came under fire in a report by the State Department's inspector general. The report charged Rosapepe with failing to inform Washington of developments in Romania, becoming too identified with Romanian policies, exercising poor judgment by including Romanian nationals in embassy meetings, and by excluding U.S. diplomats from high-level meetings with Romanian leaders. Rosapepe's information was so biased that "we really have no idea what is going on there," the inspector general's report stated.
- Likewise, many prominent socialites are frequently named to plush postings such as Barbados, which welcomed real estate heiress Joy Silverman — a Bush Sr. appointee who lacked a college degree — and U.S. Ambassador Mary Ourisman — a Bush Jr. appointee and Texas-born socialite and wife of a prominent Washington automobile dealer.
- Perhaps the most embarrassing and needlessly self-inflicted ambassadorial political appointment was that of California hotel magnate Larry Lawrence as President Clinton's envoy to Switzerland. At the time of his nomination, Lawrence had more than two dozen cases pending against him in federal tax court, prompting the American Foreign Service Association to issue an unusual and unsuccessful demand that he not be confirmed. Lawrence died in 1996 and received a waiver to be buried at Arlington National Cemetery based on his claim of having been wounded during WWII while serving in the Merchant Marines. Later, it was discovered that he never served in the Merchant Marines and that much of the rest of his life story was also fabricated. Ultimately, his body was exhumed and reburied in San Diego, and the Justice Department launched an investigation into how the State Department and White House failed to catch Lawrence's many lies during his background check.
Obama's Dilettantes
As with many newly elected presidents of an idealistic bent, Barack Obama stated that he would place more emphasis on appointing career dipomats to ambassadorial posts. In his first six months, Obama sent to the Senate 58 ambassadorial nominations. Of those 32, or 55 percent, were political appointees. In the same time period, his five predecessors made more nominations — an average of 67 — but the number of those who were political was lower at 47 percent. Oh, well.
Following is just a partial roster of the neophytes Obama has sent to top diplomatic postings in return for large payoffs in the form of "bundled" campaign contributions that circumvent the spirit, if not the letter, of campaign finance laws:
- John Roos for Japan. Roos is a California lawyer and campaign fundraiser, raising at least $500,000 for Obama's campaign; moreover, he and his immediate family gave $41,600 in campaign contributions, including $4,600 to Obama.
- Louis Susman, for the United Kingdom. A former Citigroup VP who raised at least $100,000 as an Obama bundler, he and his family contributed $239,917 to Democratic campaigns, including more than $4,000 to Obama. He also contributed $50,000 for Obama's inauguration.
- Charles Rivkin, for France. A former financial analyst at Salomon Brothers, he raised more than $500,000 for Obama and contributed $4,600 each to Obama's and Clinton's campaigns.
- Laurie Fulton, for Denmark. A corporate lawyer who runs a California entertainment company, she raised between $100,000 to $200,000 for Obama and contributed $4,100 to Obama's campaign.
Marie Antoinette of the Ardennes: The Terrible Cynthia Stroum
Poor little Grand Duchy of Luxembourg. Considered a throw-away country by the White House, this Rhode Island-sized NATO ally has always been the dumping ground for the flightiest of politically appointed U.S. ambassadors. Real estate magnates without a cause. Airhead socialites without a clue about foreign policy. Connected car salesmen who want to play Statesman for a couple of years. The Luxembourgeois have seen them come and go. Unlike our political leadership, these proud folks do not view themselves as marionettes in a toy fairytale land. They participated in the D-Day invasion and were a founding member of both the UN and the EU. They grudgingly tolerate the idiots we send as our envoys while getting the real business done through our professional diplomats and directly in Washington.
In 2009, President Obama sent as his ambassador Cynthia Stroum, a wealthy Seattle investor who raised $500,000 for Obama, putting her near the top of the campaign's rainmakers. That's $1 for every Luxembourg citizen.
She abruptly resigned one year later, just after the State Department's inspector general issued a blistering report stating the embassy "has underperformed for the entirety of the current ambassador's tenure." The report went on to describe the ambassador's managerial style as fraught with personality conflicts, verbal abuse and questionable expenditures on travel and booze. "At present, due to internal problems, it plays no significant role in policy advocacy or reporting, though developments in Luxembourg are certainly of interest to Washington clients and other U.S. missions in the NATO and EU communities."
Ambassador Stroum had so terrorized her small staff that the inspector general recommended the State Department dispatch medical personnel to examine the stress levels of embassy employees. It noted at least four quit or sought transfers to Iraq and Afghanistan during her tenure, rare actions for diplomats at a cushy European post.
"The bulk of the mission's internal problems are linked to her leadership deficiencies, the most damaging of which is an abusive management style," the report said. "She has followed a pattern of public criticism of colleagues, including (deputies), who have not performed to her satisfaction . . . Those who have questioned or challenged some of the ambassador's actions state that they have paid a heavy price in the form of verbal abuse and been threatened with dismissal," it said.
Shortly after her arrival, Stroum stressed "the importance she attaches to the perquisites of" being an ambassador. She was particularly concerned about the state of the ambassador's residence, then under renovation, it said. To locate temporary housing for her, an embassy officer spent six weeks searching for a suitable abode, investigating 200 properties. Only four met the ambassador's requirements and she rejected them all, according to the report, before an acceptable residence finally was found.
In violation of the regs, Stroum spent $2,400 of embassy funds to fly with an aide to a Swiss "professional school" which has sent graduates to work at Buckingham Palace to interview candidates to replace a retired property caretaker and a fired chef. The trip was disguised as "management meetings."
The embassy purchased $3,400 in wine and liquor a day before the 2010 budget year ended, another violation of the rules. The embassy paid for the purchase of a new ambassadorial bed because Stroum "preferred a queen bed to the king-size bed already provided."
Fleshpots and Backwaters
Transgressions by noncareer ambassadors include cocaine smuggling using diplomatic pouches, drunken imbroglios at embassy functions, embarrassing adulterous affairs, and simple ineptitude. The above cases represent a mere random sampling and fraction of the incompetence and embarrassment brought on by the diplomatic spoils system.
The upshot is that the attractive and important posts of Europe, Asia and the Caribbean are sold to moneybag charlatans, leaving malarial war zones and forgotten backwaters to the career people. What's most pathetic is the lengths to which career FSOs fight over these scraps. Men and women who would make oustanding envoys to Berlin, Tokyo and Ottawa battle like junkyard dogs to be named ambassador to Lower Slobovia.
This is not to say that all career Foreign Service officers make good managers. In fact, most are not. The Department lore is rife with tales, past and present, of so-called "super political officers" who can name every member of Kirgyzstan's government cabinet but who couldn't, as recounted about former Iraq czar Paul Bremer, "organize a two-car funeral." I could list here many more cases of career officers who were as damaging, incompetent, crazy and clueless as any political appointee. I'm thinking of devoting a separate blog entry to that subject (see "Why I Write" for a couple of examples). But a person with years of relevant training and experience certainly wins hands-down over the dilettante.
Administrations use a variety of excuses to masquerade the practice of selling ambassadorships, the most common one being that an envoy who enjoys direct access to the President can be the most effective. This is utter hogwash. Ambassadors' chain of command goes through the Secretary of State. Going outside of that chain is cause for confusion and misunderstandings and is actually frowned upon by White House and State Department officials alike.
Guts
As for a Foreign Service career "taking the guts out of people," apparently Ambassador Galbraith was unaware of the (now) 230 U.S. diplomats who have given their lives in the line of duty, including Terrence L. Barnich who was killed by a roadside bomb in Iraq on Memorial Day 2009. All 230 names are prominently displayed on memorial plaques in the Department's main entrance; hard to miss as one enters the building.
But. . . yes. You too can become a United States ambassador! The American Dream can be yours -- with a bag of swag and the proper arse-kissing.
If you have served with or under a politically appointed ambassador or other State Department official and would like to share your experiences, please leave a comment after this blog entry or on my Facebook page.
See also:
The American Diplomatic Spoils System, Part II